How much will your roof installation or replacement cost?
Columbus, OH 43215
Roofers on Thumbtack cost$80 - $100
Average fixed price
- Lowest price:$50
- Most common low price:$80
- Most common high price:$100
- Highest price:$105
Metal roof vs. shingles cost.
By Nina Kulenkampff
Last updated Tue, Oct 01
The national average total cost of an asphalt shingle roof is $12,129-$14,313. In comparison, a metal roof costs $19,570-$22,068, on average. These national average costs are for roofs that are 2,500 square feet. The cost of a new installation or a roof replacement comes down to the size of the roof (in square footage), labor cost, where you live and several other factors.
Cost of metal roof vs. shingles:
| Asphalt shingles roof | Metal roof |
|---|---|
| $12,129-$14,313 (average total cost) | $19,570-$22,068 (average total cost) |
| $5,019-$6,809 (average material cost) | $5,799-$8,168 (average material cost) |
| $7,108-$7,500 (average labor cost) | $13,771-$13,881 (average labor cost) |
| $4.85-$5.73 (average cost per square foot) | $7.83-$8.83 (average cost per square foot) |
*All figures above represent national average costs for a 2,500-square-foot roof. Material & labor costs don’t include market price fluctuations, which are included in the total average cost.
In this article, we cover the advantages and disadvantages of metal and asphalt shingle roofs and how they influence the cost of your roofing project. We also break down the shingles vs. metal roof costs in finer detail.
Once you know which material you want for your roof, reach out to a local roofing contractor for a free quote so you can get a more accurate price estimate and adjust your budget accordingly.
What's in this cost guide?
- Cost of metal roof vs. shingles:
- Which one has cheaper upfront costs: Asphalt shingles.
- Which one requires fewer repairs: Metal roof.
- Which one will last longer: Metal roof.
- Which one may help you save on energy costs: Metal roof.
- Which one is more attractive to potential buyers: Metal roof (probably).
- So, which is better – a metal roof or shingles?
- Get free cost estimates from roofing contractors near you.
Which one has cheaper upfront costs: Asphalt shingles.
Asphalt shingles have cheaper upfront costs than metal roofs. So if you have a smaller budget, a shingle roof might be the better option for you.
On average, asphalt shingle roofs typically cost $4.85-$5.73 per square foot, and a metal roof typically costs $7.83-$8.83 per square foot (including labor and material costs) in the U.S. The three main reasons the upfront costs differ between these roof options are material costs, installation complexity and roof design and preparation.
Material costs.
The popular metals used for residential roofing are typically aluminum, copper or steel. These materials are more expensive than asphalt shingles.
On average, a metal roof costs approximately $800-$1,500 per square, according to the Metal Roof Alliance (MRA). Meanwhile, an asphalt shingle roof costs $350-$900 per square.
Installation complexity.
In general, metal roofs are more complex to install when compared to asphalt shingles. Installing a metal roof can also take longer than its asphalt counterparts. This usually adds to the cost of labor.
A metal roof also needs to be installed by someone skilled and experienced. Depending on the contractor, they may charge more if they have more expertise and credentials.
Preparation.
Metal roofs need to be installed on a sturdy and even surface. If your existing roof has structural and surface issues, you may need to repair or remove damaged parts first.
Which one requires fewer repairs: Metal roof.
Extreme weather, moss and algae growth and corrosion occur more frequently with asphalt shingles. They’re also not as durable as metal, which means a shingle roof will more likely need repairs and maintenance than a metal roof. However, how often you have to maintain or repair asphalt shingles depends on your location and climate.
For example, strong winds might loosen or lift shingles, opening a gap for rain, hail or snow. You will also need to routinely clean asphalt shingles with a pressure washer to avoid debris or moss opening up gaps in between the shingles. Lastly, the waterproofing materials used in your asphalt shingle roof have a limited lifespan. These need to be maintained and eventually replaced.
Metal roofs require less maintenance than asphalt shingle roofs because metal holds up well against extreme weather. The plywood, rafters and fasteners may require repairs if damaged. But if they are of high quality and have been treated and installed correctly, then it shouldn't be a concern.
So, although metal roofs cost more upfront, you may spend less on repairs and maintenance in the long run.
Which one will last longer: Metal roof.
When weighing up the metal roof vs. shingles cost, consider how long the type of roof will last. For metal roofs, it's 40-80 years.
Asphalt shingles generally only last for close to 20-30 years. However, some companies may offer a 50-year limited warranty on their shingles.
Although the shingles may last 50 years, they must still be maintained. If you have asphalt shingles and plan on living in the home long term, chances are you'll need to do a full or major roof replacement at some point.
You also need to consider your location. For example, if you live in a region that experiences strong winds or hurricanes, a metal roof is more likely to last longer.
Which one may help you save on energy costs: Metal roof.
Metal roofs have a higher upfront cost, but with the right coating and installation, they may help you lower your energy bills in the long run.
All in all, a metal roof can save you up to 40% in energy bills, according to the MRA. Even if it’s not retrofitted with a cool coating, a metal roof may still beat asphalt shingles when it comes to energy efficiency. “The basic, unpainted metal roof will reflect more solar radiation than an asphalt roof, which absorbs and holds heat,” states the MRA.
Asphalt shingles have a bad rap for being less energy efficient than metal roofs. However, not all asphalt shingles are created equal. If you want or can afford an asphalt shingle roof, keep energy efficiency in mind when choosing your shingles.
For example, the darker the color of your shingles, the more heat your roof absorbs, raising the temperature inside your home. If you live in a hot and sunny region, choose a light color shingle that absorbs less heat and keeps your home cooler.
Are you planning on going solar?
This is a consideration for people living in regions that can save on energy costs by installing solar panels. According to Rewiring America, a solar roof may help you save hundreds of dollars every year, and you could be eligible for a tax credit.
Which one is more attractive to potential buyers: Metal roof (probably).
When deciding whether to invest in a metal roof vs. a shingle roof, consider the following points:
Aesthetics and curb appeal.
Metal roofs offer a modern look that could be more appealing to potential buyers. However, they are limited in terms of color and style options.
On the other hand, asphalt shingles can be customized to match the aesthetic of your home and other homes in your neighborhood. Do your research, and chat with a professional to find out which type of roof is more aesthetically pleasing in your area.
Durability and lifespan.
Metal roofs are more durable and have a much longer lifespan than asphalt shingles. This will save money in the long run and could be a major selling point to a potential buyer.
Energy efficiency.
We've established that metal roofs are more energy efficient. Energy costs are on the rise, and so is the trend to go green and invest in eco-friendly, energy-efficient homes. Some buyers will be more than happy to pay a little more to save money down the line.
If you consider the three points above to be the most important factors to potential homebuyers, then a metal roof wins.
Of course, homebuyers in your area may have different wants and needs when it comes to a roofing system. If you’re planning to sell your home soon, chat with a real estate professional before you make major upgrades to your existing roof.
So, which is better – a metal roof or shingles?
| Metal roof | Asphalt shingle | |
|---|---|---|
| Lower material cost | X | |
| Lower labor cost | X | |
| Lower energy costs | X | |
| Fewer repairs | X | |
| Longer lifespan | X | |
| Higher ROI/curb appeal | X |
There are advantages and disadvantages of both metal and shingle roofs. On the one hand, asphalt shingle roofs have lower material and labor costs. They are much more customizable than metal roofs. This makes them an excellent choice for people working on a lower budget.
On the other hand, shingle roofs have a relatively short lifespan and don't hold up well against extreme weather. The older and entry-level asphalt shingles are also less energy efficient than more expensive options.
Metal roofs have a much higher upfront cost. However, they are much more durable, last longer and can help you save on energy costs (with the right installation and coating).
They may also increase your curb appeal and offer you a better ROI than asphalt shingle roofs. Apart from the higher initial cost, there aren't many downsides to investing in a metal roof.
Get free cost estimates from roofing contractors near you.
Choosing the right roof comes down to personal preference, your budget and the current trends of the local housing market. If you need help deciding, download the Thumbtack app, and connect with a roofing contractor near you. They can give you free estimates and guide you along the way.
*All project cost estimates included in this article were provided by Xactware’s pricing data (unless otherwise noted). For more information, visit Xactware’s pricing methodology page.
Find local pros for your project
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll show you pros right for the job, with prices.
How do we know these prices?
5m
Customers this year
300k+
Pros this year
20k
Projects a day
How it works.
Search.
Browse profiles, see prices and use filters to find pros who match your project.
Chat.
Contact the pros you like to discuss project details.
Hire.
Check pro availability and book appointments right in the app.
You might also like
