Sis And Me Bakery

contact for price

Select a service

Zip code

Scheduling

Icing type

Number of cake tiers

Responds within a day

Introduction

My sister and I started this business together we have been decorating cakes separately for about 16 years and decided to come together in business so we have been in business about 3 years now. We are custom bakery so we try our very busy to make your vision come to life for your special event! We try not only to make it look good but it will taste amazing as well!

Overview

Hired 8 times

Serves Nappanee, IN

Background checked

2 employees

7 years in business

Business hours

This pro hasn't listed their business hours.

Payment methods

This pro accepts payments via Cash, Check, PayPal, and Venmo.

Social media

Facebook

Featured Projects

135 photos

Reviews

Customers rated this pro highly for work quality, professionalism, and value.

Exceptional 5.0

6 reviews

5

100%

4

0%

3

0%

2

0%

1

0%

Read reviews that mention:

Heather L.

Jun 5, 2021

·

Hired on Thumbtack

This was THE most amazing wedding cake we have every tasted!!! It was so full of flavor and moist!!! We received soooo many compliments on how delicious and beautiful is was! They were so professional, punctual, AND personable! I cannot recommend them enough to anyone looking for a wedding cake! Truly outstanding!!!!! **** Highly recommend!!!

Details: Traditional stack cake • Floral cake • 4 tiers • Vanilla • Whipped cream • 151 - 200 servings • Need to rent cake stands • Need delivery • At the pro’s location

Wedding Cakes

Stacy B.

Apr 3, 2022

·

Hired on Thumbtack

They did a wonderful job on a one-of-a-kind cake. My husband is addicted to old Farmall Tractors and I asked her to simulate a tractor grill into the cake. My husband and all his friends were amazed at the realism and it tasted amazing!

Details: Cakes • 4 dozen • Birthday party • Don't need delivery • At the pro’s location

Pastry Chef and Cake Making Services

Rashiinell Y.

Aug 31, 2020

·

Hired on Thumbtack

I put in my order a few weeks before my daughter party, I had no problem with getting in contact with Sis and Me Bakery! Every question I had was answered, Everything I asked was done my daughter cake was perfect! A Big hit at the party! The flavors was spot on, the coloring was what I asked for, it was moist, just all around good. I also had cupcakes and cake poppers which were great also! Pick up time was what I was told so for me, I’d travel the 45min drive again well worth it! Thanks for everything

Details: Cake Pops • Cakes • 2 dozen • Birthday party • Don't need delivery • My home, venue, etc.

Pastry Chef and Cake Making Services

Lisa T.

Nov 15, 2021

·

Hired on Thumbtack

The cake was moist and delicious. Sis and Me is easy to work with.

Details: Traditional stack cake • Standard cake • 3 tiers • Vanilla • Buttercream • 31 - 60 servings • $ (Basic) • Need to rent cake stands • Don't need delivery • At the pro’s location

Wedding Cakes

Haley W.

Aug 18, 2020

·

Hired on Thumbtack

So happy we went with Sis and Me Bakery for a cookie order for a gender reveal party - they turned out better than I could’ve imagined! Crystal was very responsive, attentive to details, and easy to work with. The cookies were perfect and they delivered them right when they said they would. Can’t wait to use them again for treats next time we have an event!

Details: Traditional stack cake • Ruffled cake • 3 tiers • Vanilla • Buttercream • 30 servings or fewer • $$ (Standard) • Don't need to rent cake stands • Need delivery • At the pro’s location

Wedding Cakes

Credentials

Background Check

Crystal Graber

FAQs

What should the customer know about your pricing (e.g., discounts, fees)?
We are a custom bakery so we can do just about anything with that being said our prices vary depending on about of fillings, design and how many you would like it to feed.
What is your typical process for working with a new customer?
We usually like to sit down and meet with the bride and grooms to talk about what exactly they want. We offer a free cake tasting and consultation.
How did you get started doing this type of work?
My grandma has done cake for 50 years and she taught me and my sister and we started out doing cakes for 4H fair and gone to state several times and then started my own business because a lot of people started loving my cake!